HomeFreeBSD

nvme: Remove a wmb() that's not necessary.

Description

nvme: Remove a wmb() that's not necessary.

bus_dmamap_sync() ensures that memory that's prepared for PREWRITE can
be DMA'd immediately after it returns. The details differ, but this
mirrors atomic thread release semantics, at least for the buffers
synced.

For non-x86 platforms, bus_dmamap_sync() has the right syncing and
fences. So in the past, wmb() had been omitted for them.

For x86 platforms, the memory ordering is already strong enough to
ensure DMA to the device sees the current contents. As such, we don't
need the wmb() here. It translates to an sfence which is only needed
for writes to regions that have the write combining attribute set or
when some exotic opcodes are used. The nvme driver does neither of
these. Since bus_dmamap_sync() includes atomic_thread_fence_rel, we
can be assured any optimizer won't reorder the bus_dmamap_sync and the
bus_space_write operations. The wmb() was a vestiage of the pre-busdma
version initially committed to the tree.

Reviewed by: kib@, gallatin@, chuck@, mav@
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D27448

Details

Provenance
impAuthored on
Differential Revision
D27448: Two commits to cleanup needless wmb() in nvme driver
Parents
rS368351: busdma: Annotate bus_dmamap_sync() with fence
Branches
Unknown
Tags
Unknown